The renewed debate over creating new provinces in Pakistan has exposed a question the country has postponed for decades, can a federation of more than 250 million people continue to govern itself through four provinces whose political and administrative structures remain heavily centralised?
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s recent call for new administrative units, followed by Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal’s proposal for 12 to 15 provinces and similar comments by Senator Rana Sanaullah, has brought the issue back into national politics. On November 12, Naqvi suggested a referendum to gauge public opinion with a rise smile on his face during a press conference .
However the proposals deserve consideration, but Pakistan must distinguish between redrawing its map and redistributing power.
The case for smaller provinces is not difficult to understand. Large provincial administrations often struggle to respond to the needs of distant regions. Residents of South Punjab have long complained of political and fiscal neglect by Lahore. The demand for a Hazara province reflects a distinct regional sense of exclusion in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Karachi, despite being the country’s economic engine, faces persistent questions about municipal authority, infrastructure and the control of resources. Similar grievances exist in other regions. Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa assemblies have passed resolutions also in support of Hazara and South Punjab provinces.
Smaller provinces may help address these grievances. They can bring provincial capitals closer to underserved populations and improve regional representation.
But size alone does not determine the quality of governance. A smaller province can reproduce the same centralisation, patronage and administrative neglect that its advocates criticise in the existing system. Replacing one distant provincial capital with a closer one will mean little if authority remains concentrated in the chief minister’s office and local governments remain financially dependent, politically subordinate or suspended at the convenience of provincial governments.
Political leaders speak of bringing government closer to the people, yet elected local governments have rarely been allowed to become durable centres of decision-making. The test is whether citizens gain meaningful control over schools, hospitals, sanitation, policing and local development.
There is also a constitutional and political reality that cannot be wished away. Altering provincial boundaries requires the procedure laid down in Article 239, including a two-thirds majority in the affected provincial assembly as well as in both houses of Parliament. Legal experts have also raised questions about the precise constitutional mechanism for creating new provinces. These safeguards reflect a federation in which provincial autonomy is part of the constitutional settlement.
A referendum, as proposed by Mr. Naqvi, could help establish public sentiment, but it cannot replace constitutional requirements or the consent of representative institutions. Any process must be transparent, negotiated and based on democratic consent, otherwise it can become another case of allegations on transparency of referendum vote counts.
Sindh’s opposition to division, for example, cannot be treated as an inconvenience. Equally, the grievances of people demanding better representation within existing provinces cannot be silenced by invoking territorial unity. Federalism requires both respect for provincial identity and responsiveness to citizens within provinces.
Before drawing new boundaries, Parliament should establish an independent, representative commission. It should consult provincial assemblies, local governments, political parties, nationalist groups, civil society and affected communities. Its work should assess population, geography, economic viability, revenue generation, water rights, natural resources, public-service access and the fair division of assets and liabilities. The process must not become a tool to advantage a ruling party or weaken a political rival.
Restructuring must also proceed alongside empowered local governments, predictable fiscal transfers and regular elections. Otherwise, Pakistan may simply multiply assemblies, ministries, secretariats and public expenditure without improving the lives of ordinary citizens.
Pakistan does not need a new map for the sake of a new map. It needs a federation in which power is not monopolised by Islamabad or provincial capitals, and in which every citizen can access the state without political connections. New provinces may be part of that answer. They are not the answer by themselves.
Leave a Reply